Issue 3016: Video is of a different dance

New issue submitted

Assigned changed to »tone2tone« (previously »None«)
Disposition changed to »Ignored« (previously »New«)

Hi Iain, I can see no discrepancy between the e-crib and the (one) video. Can you plz double check and specify what you mean?

Disposition changed to »Being handled« (previously »Ignored«)

There is perhaps one small gap in the crib: the “Touch BH” on bar 13 is danced clw in the video. That is obviously the “most dancable” way, but the crib does not mention which is right. Do we modify the crib? Eric

I still don’t get it. The crib shows exactly how I understand it and what I see in the video. When passing RS as you normally would, you just give hands.

The original instructions for the corners pass and turn of bars 9-16 just read “9-16 corners pass and turn using always BH in the middle, (even 1s couple when pass each other) briefly.” No mention of which way to pass, but right shoulder and clockwise is generally the default if not specified, especially when turning both hands. I would not normally add anything to the crib which is not mentioned in the original.

Disposition changed to »Fixed« (previously »Being handled«)

Thanks to all. Iain replied that he commented on an earlier stage where a different crib of the same deviser was shown. Crib needs no change, so I close the issue.