Issue 1077: Mistake in the SCDDB Contributed Diagrams

New issue submitted

Assigned changed to »anselm« (previously »None«)

I guess you are in charge of the Contributed Diagrams…

Disposition changed to »Needs help« (previously »New«)

This applies to [5-8] and [13-16], and also to [17] where the diagram does not show all are on opposite side.

We need to delete the diagram, unless we can ask the diagram author to correct it. Anselm: how do we find him? Or do we delete? Eric

Hi Eric, hi Anselm,

from the style of the diagram, I guess the diagram writer is Anselm himself. This is the style you could find on the Frankfurt programs long before Anselm took over SCDDB.

The numbers I was referring to were the unboxed 1 and uncircled 2 at the beginning of bar 9.

Whether the persons above the turns (bars 5-8 and 13-16) should be ordered by number (as in that diagram) or to reflect the position (as in Keiths) is a matter of taste. I have seen both over the years. And I do not mind either - although position-wise might be more intuitive here.

So basically, Anselm has to decide what to do with ‘his’ diagram ;) That’s why I have assigned this to Anselm in the first place…

Would there be an easy way to initiate a reminder to the person the issue is assigned to every once in a while if the disposition is not “fixed” or “ignored”? Currently, I think only the ‘Eric-App’ is going through open issues from time to time ;)

Cheers, Heiko

Reminder ;-) yes, bar 9 with the unboxed persons is wrong, they should be changed. As with some other diagram before, I think it would be best to delete the diagram altogether now that we have a Keith Rose diagram for it, which to me is Anselm’s choice and task.

Disposition changed to »Fixed« (previously »Needs help«)

Removed the erroneous diagram.

I have added the progression (2,1) in the e-crib Eric